Financial survival of woman pensioners of retirement schemes in SA
By Bruce Cameron 5 April 2020
Alexander Forbes recently released the first major research on the financial survival of pensioners of retirement schemes in SA – and it does not make happy reading for women. This research was done before the Covid-19 outbreak and Moody’s downgraded South Africa. The situation now is likely to be far worse.
Women in retirement are far worse off financially than men.
The reasons include: insufficient contribution rates to retirement funds, breaks in careers to raise a family, the glass ceiling and, in retirement, the fact that they live longer than men.
Incidentally the World Economic Forum’s 2018 Global Gender Gap Report has South Africa in 19th place out of 149 countries. Things are getting better for women but they are still far from acceptable.
This is backed by research undertaken by Alexander Forbes on its own largest retirement book in the country.
Actuary, John Anderson, Alexander Forbes head of strategic development, says the proportion of women in higher earning positions has increased over the last decade.
He says this is likely to be a result of changes in the types of work given the advancement of technology, cost-of-living changes generally making it necessary for as many family members as possible to work and changes in the environment to encourage and embrace diversity and equality in the workplace.
“We are also seeing many more women being appointed to the boards of companies as well as being appointed as CEO’s. The portion of women in the R960 000 plus salary band is now seven times higher than in 2010.”
More and more retirees and fund members are now female.
Anderson says female fund members have now increased by about 17% in 2012 by 39,31% to 46,04% in 2019.
Women now dominate membership in the personal services, professional and business services and in the retail, wholesale and hospitality sectors of the economy. Their lowest membership of women is in the mining and construction sectors, which are still dominated and likely to remain dominated by male members.
Anderson says that the research into retirees finances, shows that the amount of money with which women retire has grown significantly from 1998 to 2018.
Women are ahead in the R600 000 to R1 500 000 retirement capital group at retirement. In the R20 million plus group, where they had no representations before, they now hold 25 percent of the assets.
Apart from the one group, all the other retirement savings sectors men are ahead. The lowest sector for women is the R10 million to R20 million group where they only hold 21% of the capital.
Women members, in the build-up to retirement, are still disadvantaged in other ways. For example, by having babies and/or raising a family, getting divorced and looking after children, resulting in breaks in their careers or the ability to work full-time.
And then comes retirement where they live longer on average than men. At age 60 the expected average age of death for women is 84 and for men it is 79.
The consequence of this is shown immediately in traditional guaranteed annuities where women receive less than men. In 2019 the average return (pension) paid to a women, investing R1million at retirement at age 65, would have been R8 750 a month, against a male who would have received R8 950.
Anderson says that the replacement ratio, which is the expected pension as a proportion of final salary, for retirees in 2019 was 25,4% for females and 27,8% for males.
The replacement ratio breakdown of retirees for 2019 was as follows:
Replacement ratio Men Women
0% to 20% 49,9% 51,6%
20% to 40% 24,0% 27,9%
40% to 60% 13,5% 11,8%
60% to 80% 7,7% 5,6%
80%+ 4,9% 3,1%
Anderson says, compounding the lower replacement ratio, is the average drawdowns by women from investment linked living annuities (illas) is higher than that for men.
This is far to low for most people to retire on. You should have at least a replacement ration of at 60% but probably closer to 100%.
Anderson says that this this is concerning as women actually need more retirement capital than men. It again shows the problems for women in the build-up in retirement savings.
Based on actual research, comparing men with women, an investment linked living annuity the average drawdowns where the retiree takes the risk of capital lasting till they die, is again the wrong way around:
Retirement Age Men Women
55 to 60 5,8% 6,36%
60 to 65 5,27% 5,72%
65 to 70 5,30% 6,07%
70 to 75 5,61% 7,47%
75+ 5,53% 8,97%
Anderson says that females, looking to options to ensure their basic income needs against longevity, these higher drawdown rates will boil through to an earlier “point of ruin” where your income drawdown goes up rapidly to the maximum drawdown of 17,5% and will then reduce in Rand terms in both real and before-inflation returns.
Any initial drawdown, at age 65, above 4% is likely to result in a “point of ruin” in the years ahead.
Anderson say another factor which women face is that because men, who die earlier on average, often die of diseases that are expensive to treat, this can wipe out any other assets leaving the window to suffer the consequences.
Anderson says there are some rules women should follow to improve their income in retirement these include:
Sign up for a retirement fund as soon as you can. Preferably from your first pay check.
Build up an emergency savings of between 3 and 6 months’ income for tough times alongside your retirement savings.
Realise that any employment-based retirement fund is not likely to give you the required replacement ratio at retirement. You will need to top this up with contributions to a retirement annuity. The tax advantage are fantastic. You can contribution in total savings to a retirement fund 27,5 percent of your taxable income to a maximum of R350 000 on which no tax is paid.
Do not use your retirement funds as a back-up for a family business and do not cash them in and transfer the money to the ownership of a partner.
Preserve your retirement savings for retirement. This is the main cause of why people do not have a financially stable pension in retirement.
If you are having babies or raising a family, have your husband or partner make contributions to your retirement fund. If you married or are in a permanent relationship this will make your retirement years so much better, and will be a life saver if you get divorced.
If you get divorced make sure you get your rightful share of your partners retirement savings. Then invest that amount in a retirement annuity. Don’t use it for anything else.
Continue working for as long as possible before retiring.
Invest your retirement savings in an appropriate and diversified growth strategy when you are young.
Do not make high risk investments at retirement
At retirement, structure your income so that it will meet your on-going financial needs.
At retirement, consider assuring your basic income needs against longevity to avoid running out of money to cover these necessities. The main assurance vehicle is a guaranteed for life pension bought from a life assurance company which is guaranteed to keep paying a pension until you die.
Ensure you manage your expenses in retirement keeping them in line with your spending.
Over the next number of weeks a series of reports written by Bruce Cameron, the semi-retired founding editor of Personal Finance of Independent Newspapers, will cover research undertaken by Alexander Forbes on retirement income in South Africa. Bruce Cameron is co-author of the best-selling book, The Ultimate Guide to Retirement in South Africa.
Contact Ascor®Independent Wealth Managers for retirement planning advice.